Definition : Rebuttable presumption

Legal presumption that can be rebutted or challenged by evidence to the contrary (e.g. the presumption of liability of the custodian of a property or the presumption that a undived co-owner absent at a meeting of co-owners consents to the other co-owners representing him, if he has not, in writing, mandated a third person for that purpose or has indicated his refusal to be represented.). Its antonym is irrebuttable presumption.

Related articles

{alt}
lock
You need to have an account to read this article

02/07/2025

Proxy: Does the presumption of mandate apply in phased co-ownership?

I have to preside over the meeting of co-owners of the initial syndicate of a phased co-ownership, often mistakenly referred to as a horizontal co-ownership. This co-ownership consists of three buildings, each governed by its own declaration of co-ownership. I am wondering about the status of the co-owners of these…...

Syndicate
{alt}

13/11/2024

Insurance deductible: What proof must the Syndicate provide to obtain reimbursement?

A recent decision by the Court of Québec provides important clarifications for co-ownership syndicates seeking to recover insurance deductibles from co-owners in the event of a claim. In this ruling, the Court dismissed a syndicate’s request for a co-owner to reimburse a deductible of $50,014.13 following water damage that occurred…...

Insurance

21/03/2024

Civil liability of a co-owner in the event of water damage

In divided co-ownership, a water damage incident almost inevitably raises the issue of the civil liability of the co-owner, the syndicate or, depending on the circumstances, a third party such as an occupant or a tenant. These frequent losses, particularly those resulting from the failure of a water heater or…...

Management

13/11/2021

Responsabilité des copropriétaires en cas de sinistre: une réforme s’impose!

Deux (2) jugements[1] récents rendus par l’Honorable juge Georges Massol, de la Cour du Québec, abordent l’article 1074.2 du Code civil du Québec et le sens qu’il faudrait donner à cette disposition introduite au Code civil du Québec en décembre 2018 et qui a été modifié en mars 2020. L’audition de…...

Insurance